PASADENA STAR NEWS December 18, 2007

HEADLINE: Revised testing rules should improve NCLB

TALKS in Congress over reauthorization of the federal No Child Left Behind law have not been going well. With discussions stalled and pressure from the states mounting, the Bush administration recently granted the states new flexibility in tracking student achievement. Federal education officials will allow states to evaluate individual student progress, rather than simply comparing one year's group of students to another year's. Though much remains to be done to fix other flaws in the law, this concession is a step in the right direction.

Under current federal rules, schools must report how this year's third graders, for example, performed compared to last year's third graders on reading and math tests. Those assessments matter for schools; if benchmark goals are missed, schools can be cited and penalized for failing to make what the law calls "adequate yearly progress."

But that measurement offers only limited snapshots of student abilities. It is imprecise and unfair because it looks only at groups of students, without considering individual gains.

A better way to measure achievement, known as a value-added or growth model, requires schools to assess the progress of individual students over time. To do that, states must have good methods of tracking test scores that also protect student privacy.

Previously, the department had allowed eight states to experiment with growth model testing. Now Education Secretary Margaret Spellings says she is expanding the pilot program because many states have improved their efforts to collect and protect information about individual students.

The change reflects a set of good recommendations outlined earlier this year by a group of legislators and educators.

Members of Congress rightly continue to debate various aspects of NCLB. Despite disagreements on other issues, most support the new method of measuring student gains.

Congress can turn its attention to provisions that, among other things, properly fund mandates and make the rules less punitive and more supportive. Congress is making progress; "adequate" is still a ways off.